Archdiocese Investigates Mishandled Funds at Troy Catholic Church
The Rev. Edward Belczak was asked to step down from the St. Thomas More Parish in Troy after an audit revealed he may have misappropriated $429,000 over six years.
One Troy church, and its leadership, is under the microscope this week after the Archdiocese of Detroit announced that more than $400,000 had gone missing under the leadership of one priest.
The Rev. Edward Belczak was asked to step aside earlier this week as pastor at the St. Thomas More Catholic Church, located on North Adams Road, after an audit by the Archdiocese of Detroit revealed "questionable financial transactions and practices."
In total, according to a statement released by the archdiocese Tuesday, Belczak may have misappropriated $429,000 over six years, funneling some of that money to pay his salary and some to a "ghost employee."
During the investigation involving both the archdiocese and the Troy Police Department, Belczak has been removed from the office of pastor and will not be staying at his residence on church grounds. Msgr. John Zenz, head of Birmingham's Holy Name Catholic Church, will take over the administrative duties of the parish during the investigation.
According to the archdiocese's statement, Belczak's public ministry as a priest is not impacted at this time.
In total, the alleged mismanagement of funds includes:
- Taking excess compensation beyond the church's policies, resulting in an estimated loss of $92,000 to parish over six years.
- Accepting and directing about $16,000 in funds to himself that should have been poste to parish accounts.
- Paying a "ghost employee" $240,000, benefits included, over the past six years.
- Maintaining improper medical/dental insurance coverage for an individual, resulting in a $26,000 loss to the parish over six years.
- Authorizing a long-term disability policy for an employee while not providing a similar benefit to other parish staff members, a loss of $20,000.
- Allowing the St. Thomas More Travel Group to be a parish-related activity though none of the group's financial transactions were disclosed for financial reporting.
- Accepting residual commission checks to St. Thomas more Travel Group while not depositing them, a loss of $25,000.
- Failing to record and deposit money received through the Mother's Day and Father's Day special collections according to church policies.
Belczak has been at St. Thomas More since 1984, before that working as an associate pastor at Our Lady Of Sorrows in Farmington, and as a co-pastor and associate pastor at the National Shrine of the Little Flower in Royal Oak.
Belczak was ordained in 1972, receiving his education at the Sacred Heart Seminary in Detroit and St. John's Provincial Seminary in Plymouth.
On the Troy Patch Facebook page, the reaction was largely shocked and sympathetic to Belczak.
"As a longtime parishoner of (St. Thomas More), this is shocking to me and saddens me so much," wrote Amy Pasternak Gora.
"Fr. Belczak is not an accountant, he is a great priest and we support him 100 percent," added Jean Crane.
Besides serving at Birmingham's Holy Name Church, Zenz is also episcopal vicor for the Northwest Region and will remain at St. Thomas More during the investigation.
According to a report in the Detroit Free Press, St. Thomas serves about 2,500 families in Oakland County.
Neither Belczak nor Zenz could be reached for comment Wednesday.
JAMES KLEINSCHMIDT
5:00 pm on Wednesday, January 23, 2013
This priest is treated badly. Most of the audit will probably be explained as not meeting Diocese standards, but hardly fraud. For instance, the"ghost employee" could easily be one or more sub-contractractors hired, because it easier than the complications of hiring a full-time employee (benefits, 401k, taxes, etc.). The "extra income" could be gifts from parishioners. Not promptly turning in collections is not a crime, if no one is enriching themselves. The travel club? Sounds like the
Diocese wants a cut.
This looks like., possibly, incompetent or malicious politics on the part of the Diocese.
Maureen Feely
7:51 pm on Wednesday, January 23, 2013
Why are they not mentioning the woman who was in charge of the books? Fr. Belczak was not the parish bookkeeper. The news media is only after sensationalism. Another Catholic priest in "trouble".
BoB
10:11 pm on Saturday, April 6, 2013
We will never know unless a criminal trial which will never happen. Who is going to prosecute? The Church? He has already received his punishment and will me a lay-therapist next year.
Hayley McInerney
10:23 pm on Wednesday, January 23, 2013
My heart is breaking upon hearing this news. Father Belczak has been one of the most influential religious people in my life, and has always been someone I admire and trust. I can only pray that this is a huge misunderstanding.
Mark
4:18 am on Saturday, January 26, 2013
Wow, I'm shocked by the rush to defend this man. A 450,000 clerical error? Spend ten seconds with Ed, and it becomes painfully obvious that this man is of highly limited spiritual presence, hardly a moral presence. I can't believe so many were fleeced by this man, an obvious charlatan, and, worse yet, willing to defend him even now.
Dale
8:57 pm on Sunday, March 31, 2013
Let he who is without sin throw the first stone. The Archbishop and the diocese of Detroit crucified Fr. Belczak in the press just like the high priests and pharisees crucified Jesus.
Ray Cruz
8:57 pm on Friday, April 5, 2013
@Dale. I liked Father Ed and he presided over religious events in my life over most of my life, but comparing him to Jesus and quoting the bible? Get real. This is a civil issue and he will be investigated by the FEDERAL Bureau of Investigation and will most likely appear before a jury of his peers. How can you explain away over 400 grand by saying something religious. This is an earthly matter first.
THEODORE GIBSON
12:54 pm on Sunday, January 27, 2013
The truth will prevail. The Catholic Church would never try to cover up a scandal.
William Therrian
1:43 pm on Sunday, January 27, 2013
This to and more shall be revealed... $429.000 is rarely a mistake, but maybe more likely dishonesty and a cover up. We will pray that the truths Will be known .
William Therrian
2:03 pm on Sunday, January 27, 2013
Matthew 10:26 (KJV)
Fear them not therefore: for there is nothing covered, that shall not be revealed; and hid, that shall not be known.
Jim Koczara
2:21 pm on Monday, January 28, 2013
I think the problem may be that Fr. Belczak had a hard tim saying no to his.parishiners. he was such a positive guy and always had a can do spirit. We had him for four wonderful years at Our Lady of Sorrows in Farmington. It was a sad day when he left. I hope this all goes away and we only say of Father Belczak that he was the best!
I