patching...
Welcome back, Patch Blogger!

Troy Residents Speak Out; Mayor Janice Daniels' Future Uncertain

Public comment for and against Troy Mayor Janice Daniels dominated Monday night's Troy City Council meeting.

 

Janice Daniels remained mayor of Troy Tuesday morning, despite the best efforts of dozens of residents who vocally urged the embattled mayor to resign during Monday evening's 5 1/2-hour Troy City Council meeting.

Daniels – who has been under fire since Friday for using a gay slur in a June Facebook status update – broke her silence with an apology Monday morning before showing up briefly at a protest organized by the Troy High School Gay-Straight Alliance at Troy City Hall Monday afternoon, where she was not well received by the protesters.

At Monday evening's Troy City Council meeting, many residents were angry with Daniels' use of a gay slur and the negative attention her comment has garnered nationwide, and in a marathon public comment session many questioned her ability continue to perform as mayor of Troy.

Especially eloquent were several Troy High School students who spoke early in the meeting. "This isn't an issue about sexuality ... this is about being human," said Troy High senior Skye Curtis, co-founder of the school's Gay-Straight Alliance.

"The part of this ordeal that is the most morally repugnant to me is the lack of thought that Mayor Daniels put into this ... Daniels' casual use of an outdated slur has had the greatest possible impact on the most innocent members of her constituency, Troy's youth. We are too young to vote but we are not too young to be impacted by your words."

Sabrina Lee, the co-founder with Curtis of the school's GSA, said that when she moved last year to Troy from Pittsburgh, the thing she noticed was its diversity. "I came from a place where it's not uncommon to see people getting hurt based on who they love. Then I came to Troy where I could be openly gay without being bullied for it. ...

"Since you do not believe in equality, I feel more alienated than ever in my city. If you do not believe in equality for all, then you do not believe in equality at all."

"Mayor Daniels – and especially the Troy City Council – the limelight is on you," said Denise Brogan-Kator, executive director of Equality Michigan. "This is your moment; make the best of it. You can do better, and the people of Troy deserve better."

"We celebrate and embrace diversity, and we are so proud of our community tonight," said Michelle Hodges, president of the Troy Chamber of Commerce. "I urge everybody here and everybody listening to not penalize the business community for what has happened."

"We came here tonight because we wanted Mayor Daniels to have a really good look at – and to meet for maybe the first time in her entire life – a gay family," Birmingham resident Amy Weber said. Amy and her wife, Tina, spoke directly to Daniels during public comment, and the couple's two young daughters brought drawings to give to the mayor.

Troy resident Cynthia Wilshire said she's lived in the city for 55 years and that "I've never been so ashamed and embarassed and angry as I was Saturday morning when I got up in the morning to turn on the news and to hear ... what you said.

"Shame on you. Shame on you. And to all of you council people? You are to represent all of us, with your best behavior. This was not good behavior. Your personal opinions should not be the basis of your decisions. You are behaving like Congress."

"This is very serious, because if it isn't the gay people, it's going to be the Polish, or the Jewish, or the Muslim," Toby Gosselin said during public comment. "Your hatred and your prejudice is intolerable, and it needs to go."

Gosselin's comment, along with many others Monday night, drew applause and cheers from the audience, though some of Daniels' supporters commented.

"I came out to support the mayor," Troy resident Barb Yagley said. "I don't think that inflammatory language is ever appropriate. She showed a serious error in judgment in using that word."

Throughout the meeting, Daniels, who remained expressionless during comments, listened to residents' concerns and comments attentively.

Shortly before midnight, the council voted unanimously to continue the meeting and allow more public comments. After that, council members had their say. The meeting officially ended just after 1 a.m. Tuesday, at which time the mayor made a brief statement to Patch.

"I'm so tired," Daniels said. "I wish I could think of something really nice to say, but I can't think of something that would be absolutely appropriate.

"I'm very, very moved by the whole experience," she continued, "and I'm going to be making some considerations certainly in the future."

For a replay of last night's meeting on Patch, click here. For all of our stories relating to the recent controversy surrounding Troy Mayor Janice Daniels, visit our special topic page.

Related Topics: Janice Daniels and Troy Manager
Did you watch the City Council meeting streamed live or in person? Tell us in the comments.

canseeallsides

7:19 am on Tuesday, December 6, 2011

It's more than her, shine the light toward the other city servants and you will see they are mostly bullies too and worse! Not all of them but no question, there is a systemic, institutional problem that is taught, maintained and covered from the top down.

Go to every council meeting and tell them how you feel, it will be more effective than saying it on here! Call them, write them, email them, post on every blog. Shine the light in these dark spirits before it is too late!
Good Luck Troy, you need it!

WE'RE GOING TO BOYCOTT TROY
http://boycotttroy.com

Reply
Comment_arrow

Bob

5:56 pm on Wednesday, December 7, 2011

You are so right! I am a retired employee from Troy and I can tell you that there is a bullying arrogant attitude prevalent throughout. I would be embarrassed to say I lived in Troy at this point. So many possibilities but so little qualified leadership. Get off your high horses and try working with people for everyone's good.

Eve Parsons

7:44 am on Tuesday, December 6, 2011

Does the City of Troy have a Code of Conduct? Does it apply to City Council & Mayor?

Reply

Nancy Hanus

8:09 am on Tuesday, December 6, 2011

Eve: Maureen McGinnis spoke about the code of conduct after the public comment and while council members were addressing the mayor, well after most people left the meeting. Some of that is here: http://patch.com/A-pn7J but you can see the whole of her comments when the city puts up the archived video of the meeting. McGinnis urged everyone on the council to sign the code; apparently the last time it was signed was more than a year ago, before the mayor and two new other members joined the council.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Tim McGee

12:40 pm on Tuesday, December 6, 2011

Nancy: There is a major differance between a city employee's "Code of Conduct" and the "Council Ethics Policy" that Maureen recommended be updated and signed by the council. CM Slater's comments about what would happen to a city employee if a slur like Ms. Daniels was publically uttered would most likely result in an end of employment. I agree that Ms. Daniels and all of the council members are in facto "employees" of the city and should be held accountable just as much as our policemen, office workers, etc. There is a city Code of Conduct and the council should be held to those standards in addition to the council Code of Ethics.

Comment_arrow

Eve Parsons

8:27 pm on Tuesday, December 6, 2011

City Council's Code of Ethics was signed on 10/18/10. Read it carefully. Meeting attendance & being informed are addressed - respect for all people & refraining from hate speech are not. Document is incomplete & CC needs to bring it up to a standard which will reflect the values the Troy Community holds dear. Only then, can this piece of paper be called a "Code of Ethics".
Ethics:
1. system of moral principles
2. rules of conduct recognized in respect to a particular class of human actions or a particular group
3. moral principles, as of an individual
4. that branch of philosophy dealing with values relating to human conduct, with respect to the rightness and wrongness of certain actions and to the goodness and badness of the motives and ends of such actions.

Not only does the document lack key principles, but apparently it isn't of importance to those recently elected – none have signed it. Documents like a Code of Ethics are a key part of the hiring process & are signed on Day 1 of a job - like right after being sworn in?
As the current C of E doesn't address hate speech, I was wondering if issue is covered in another document such as Troy Code of Conduct? If so, does the City's Code of Conduct apply to the Mayor & Council or do they abide by a totally separate set of rules?
Is it too much for citizens to expect that any candidate for office in the great city of Troy has the ability to meet basic standards of behavior such not using hate speech?

cath

2:11 pm on Tuesday, December 6, 2011

This mayor is a mess... she needs to go. Her beliefs and plans for troy are not good for this city. Being homophobic and against the transit center really aren't helping troy at all.

Reply

Linda

4:17 pm on Wednesday, December 7, 2011

I find it totally ludicrous that she doesn't want the Federal money that is being offered to Troy, but says she is for the Transit Center and that Troy should start a savings account from our general fund to pay for it later.

She also wanted to use the general fund for the library, thinks we have loads of money and doesn't have a clue about budgets. On one of the radiio shows she even said that the voters voted for a millage to keep the library open on Saturdays. NO, Janice, the voters voted to keep the library OPEN as it was. Maybe she should start reading up on things concerning Troy.

Where did they find this woman?

Reply
Comment_arrow

Lucille Musser Arking

1:05 pm on Tuesday, January 10, 2012

They do have a code of ethics but this mayor wants to make her own rules. for some reason she thinks she is smarter then thousand of years of public leaders who developed protocals for government order of meetings etc.

Comment_arrow

Lucille Musser Arking

1:07 pm on Tuesday, January 10, 2012

She was at every city council meetings and those who voted for her either liked her style or never watched her at city council meetings . I did not vote for her because I knew from her behavior at public comments that she was loose cannon and that she had no leadership skills . Iam so sorry for Troy that I was right but others never wt=atched or behavior or thought it appropriate.

Comment_arrow

Ron of Troy

11:20 pm on Thursday, January 12, 2012

For many years, during the wealthy days of Michigan, we sent considerable sums of our tax money to Washington. It was then distributed to the less well off states. It would be a good thing to get some more money coming back into the State of Michigan and to Troy now. The Mayor's apparent fiscal approach to the Federal Government is driving her goals for Troy.

Kimberley Cece

4:55 pm on Wednesday, December 7, 2011

I watched the meeting and heard the comments. While some were stated to make this into a movement for gay rights in Troy, the comments that I was attentive to were the ones admonishing her use of the Q word. Not all of us will disagree with her opinion about marriage rights for gays, but we vehemently disagree with the mean and reckless use of the Q word. I wish that this light is not now showing on Troy for negative reasons...and for that...I believe that we should replace her with someone more responsible and cautious. We do not need the lot of us who live here to be seen as haters. By making that comment in such a public forum and in a mean spirited fashion, I fear the Mayor has opened up a veritable bottomless can of worms.

Reply

Leave a comment